Our Blog

Karen's Connection

March 02, 2017

Goodville Mutual has a reputation for being a family-oriented company.  But did you know that you can still find relatives of the very first employees working at Goodville today?

Read More...

Karen Gingrich currently works as our State Filing and Underwriting Programs Coordinator, and she has been with Goodville for over 30 years.  She also has a connection that stretches back to the beginnings of Goodville.

Karen's great-grandfather was George Sauder, the very first president of Goodville Mutual Casualty Company in 1926.  George Sauder is known as a great businessman, but he is also remembered as a family man.

Karen knew her great-grandfather into her early teen years.  He loved reading, studying, and writing about local history.  Karen’s mother remembers visiting him and always finding a stack of books by his couch.  He would attain a fresh supply of reading material from the local library on wheels, which occasionally stopped at the house.  Karen remembers, “It was a special treat to receive books from him for Christmas."

Karen's mother, Ruth Ann, with her grandfather, George, out for a boat ride.  This was around 1950.  Her mother was proud to become his first grandchild to graduate from high school.

Karen’s two great-aunts, Virginia (Sauder) Hoover and Kathryn (Sauder) Hershey, are the last surviving children of her great-grandfather.  They are the younger sisters of Karen’s maternal grandmother, Celestine (Sauder) Eberly.  Virginia proudly reached the age of 97 this past year!

(From left) Virginia (Sauder) Hoover, her sister Kathryn (Sauder) Hershey, Kathryn’s husband Eby Hershey, and Karen.  Their father was George Sauder, and they are Karen’s great-aunts.

The First Office Employee

Karen sat down with Virginia this past December to talk about the family’s connection to Goodville Mutual.  It turns out that Virginia played a large role in Goodville’s success!  “She was the third office employee and was the only person in the office most of the time.  She did everything, except work in claims!”

Virginia worked for Goodville from 1938 to 1940.  She worked out of the “first office”, which was located in Wayne S. Martin Sr.’s home in Goodville, PA.  Wayne Martin was Goodville’s first secretary.  Karen asked Virginia how many people worked with her in the office.  She replied, “It was only me”.  She performed practically every job necessary to keep Goodville running.  The only jobs she did not perform were settling claims, which were handled through the church.

During this time frame, Goodville purchased a typewriter to keep up with the times.  Virginia taught herself how to use it and began to type every policy.

She sent out all the billing statements.  She “squared up the books” at the end of the month.  Occasionally, she would even answer the phones.

Her father, George, came to the office every week to sign the policies.  Virginia would then carry all the signed policies to the Goodville Post Office.  This office was located across the street from Goodville Mutual’s office, inside of the local hardware store.

Connecting the Past to Today

After reflecting on these details of Goodville’s past and her family’s history, Karen shared, “It’s been interesting to have this link back to the beginning of the company”.  Virginia and Kathryn are proud that Karen is still working with the company and “carrying on the legacy”.

With the photos of our past presidents lining our hallway, she often passes her great-grandfather’s picture.  She wonders “what would he think of all the changes in the insurance industry that have taken place during the 90 years that Goodville has been in existence”.

George Sauder’s picture that hangs on the wall in Goodville’s New Holland, PA headquarters.

But George Sauder is no stranger to innovative ideas.  With the emergence of the automobile and the destruction it was proven to cause, George and the other founders wanted to provide a way to help their church members be responsible for accidents.  They believed in bearing one another’s burdens.  For this very reason, Karen believes her great-grandfather would have embraced all of the new technology in today’s world.

Karen also believes her great-grandfather and the other founders “would be proud of the enduring values that are still a part of our business today”.  The strong roots that started Goodville have helped elevate us to success throughout the years and will help us continue serving our policyholders with quality service.


Goodville Mutual welcomes Bruce Brizzi as VP of Marketing

April 16, 2018

Goodville Mutual Casualty Company is pleased to welcome Bruce Brizzi as Vice President of Marketing.  In his role, Bruce will lead Goodville's sales and marketing team during a time of continued growth for the company.

Read More...

Bruce has worked in the P&C industry for over 30 years, most recently working as Executive Vice President of Insurance Operations at Northern Neck Insurance Company, a mutual insurance company serving the Commonwealth of Virginia.  Before his time at Northern Neck, Bruce was employed by Travelers Insurance Company for 17 years, leading claim center operations in several states before transitioning into the role of Regional Vice President for Personal Insurance, responsible for production, profitability, and agency relationships.

Bruce grew up in western Pennsylvania and earned a B.S. degree in Business Management from Clarion University of Pennsylvania.

"We are excited to have Bruce join the Goodville team," said David Gautsche, President and CEO of Goodville.  "The diverse experience he brings will be invaluable as we work collaboratively with our agency partners to accomplish our strategic objectives!"

Goodville Mutual recognized as top 50 property and casualty insurance company for ninth year in a row

July 17, 2018

Ward Group recently revealed its 2018 Ward’s 50 Property and Casualty Top Performers list.  For the ninth consecutive year, Goodville Mutual has been named to the list as one of the top 50 property and casualty companies in the nation.

Read More...

Each year, Ward Group analyzes the financial performance of nearly 3,000 property-casualty insurance companies in the U.S. to identify the top performers.  As a Ward’s 50 company, we are recognized for our consistency, safety, and superior financial performance.

“We are honored to be named to the Ward’s Top 50 for the ninth year in a row,” said David Gautsche, President and CEO of Goodville Mutual.  “Recognition from this industry benchmarking expert affirms our reputation as a strong and stable industry leader.  This achievement is the result of solid business planning and continued hard work by our agencies and employees committed to upholding policyholder protection and service.”

We’re proud of this achievement, and we thank the agents, policyholders, and employees who make this possible year-after-year.

About Ward Group: Ward Group within McLagan is the leading provider of benchmarking and best practices studies for the insurance industry.  Areas of analysis are staff levels, compensation, business practices, and expenses for all areas of insurance company operations. 

About Goodville Mutual: Founded in 1926, Goodville Mutual is a property and casualty insurance company offering coverages to personal, small business, church, and farm clients through independent agents in Virginia, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Delaware.